| |
|
| Article Heatmap Negative Neutral Positive No Data | Aggregates | Weighted Mean | +0.22 | Unweighted Mean | +0.20 | | Max | +0.46 Article 19 | Min | +0.10 Article 30 | | Signal | 17 | No Data | 14 | | Confidence | 23% | Volatility | 0.09 (Low) | | Negative | 0 | Channels | E: 0.4 S: 0.6 | | SETL | -0.01 | Structural-dominant | Evidence: High: 1 Medium: 7 Low: 9 No Data: 14 | Theme Radar | | Domain Context Profile | Element | Modifier | Affects | Note | | Privacy | +0.05 | Article 12 | HN collects minimal user data; transparent privacy policy; user anonymity supported | | Terms of Service | +0.03 | Article 19 | TOS permits wide editorial expression; no content restrictions on discussion topics | | Accessibility | +0.02 | Article 25 | Basic web accessibility; text-based interface; no specialized accessibility features noted | | Mission | +0.08 | Article 19 Article 20 | Platform explicitly designed for open discussion and knowledge sharing; supports freedom of expression | | Editorial Code | — | | Community moderation; minimal editorial gatekeeping by operators | | Ownership | +0.02 | Article 21 | Privately owned but operates as public commons; transparent ownership | | Access Model | +0.10 | Article 25 Article 27 | Free, open access to discussion; no subscription barrier; supports equal access to information | | Ad/Tracking | -0.02 | Article 12 | Minimal advertising; some tracking present but limited compared to mainstream social platforms | | | Score Breakdown +0.23 Medium P-community F-collaborative Post embodies collaborative knowledge-seeking; platform structure supports open discourse and mutual aid +0.15 Article 1 Freedom, Equality, Brotherhood Low P-equal F-dignity Community treats all members with equal standing in discussion; no inherent hierarchy +0.11 Article 2 Non-Discrimination Low P-inclusive Post openly seeks input from diverse perspectives; no discrimination evident ND Article 3 Life, Liberty, Security Right to life not directly addressed in technical discussion context ND Slavery/forced labor not relevant to this technical discussion ND Torture/cruelty not relevant to this technical discussion ND Article 6 Legal Personhood Right to legal personhood not relevant to this technical discussion +0.17 Article 7 Equality Before Law Low P-equal Platform treats all users equally before community standards; no discrimination in discussion forum ND Article 8 Right to Remedy Effective remedy not directly relevant to this discussion context ND Article 9 No Arbitrary Detention Arbitrary arrest/detention not relevant to technical discussion ND Fair trial procedure not relevant to this context ND Article 11 Presumption of Innocence Criminality and punishment not relevant to this discussion +0.20 Medium P-privacy P-minimal-tracking HN platform provides reasonable privacy protections; pseudonymity available; minimal invasive tracking +0.28 Article 13 Freedom of Movement Medium P-freedom-movement F-open-discussion Post demonstrates freedom to seek and share information across platforms; no restrictions on topic discussion ND Right to asylum not relevant to technical discussion context ND Nationality not relevant to this technical discussion ND Article 16 Marriage & Family Marriage and family not relevant to this technical discussion ND Property rights not directly addressed in this discussion +0.24 Article 18 Freedom of Thought Medium P-conscience F-open-belief Post expresses free thought and opinion about tool preferences; platform enables open expression of preferences +0.46 Article 19 Freedom of Expression High P-opinion P-expression P-receive-information Post directly exercises freedom to seek, receive, and share information; HN explicitly enables this freedom; no editorial censorship observed +0.33 Article 20 Assembly & Association Medium P-assembly P-association Post represents voluntary association in community discussion; no forced participation; free to engage or withdraw +0.18 Article 21 Political Participation Medium P-participation Community participation available to all; voting mechanisms present; equal voice in discussion threads +0.11 Article 22 Social Security Low P-social-support Community provides informal knowledge-sharing support; peer assistance observable in discussion ND Article 23 Work & Equal Pay Employment and work conditions not directly relevant to this discussion ND Article 24 Rest & Leisure Rest and leisure not directly relevant to this technical discussion +0.17 Article 25 Standard of Living Low P-access Free access to discussion platform supports standard of living; no paywall; accessible to all with internet +0.11 Low P-education Discussion demonstrates knowledge-seeking behavior; community shares expertise; informal education enabled +0.25 Article 27 Cultural Participation Medium P-culture P-participate-benefits Post engages with open-source tool culture; HN community shares scientific and cultural knowledge; benefits accessible to all participants +0.11 Article 28 Social & International Order Low P-order Platform operates within stable framework; community norms facilitate order; minimal disruption observed +0.13 Article 29 Duties to Community Low P-responsibility Post demonstrates responsible tool evaluation; community standards encourage thoughtful participation +0.10 Article 30 No Destruction of Rights Low P-prevent-abuse Platform policies prevent misuse of rights; community norms protect discourse; no evidence of right destruction | |
| |